Buying homes that are yet to be built is a trend that is drawing a lot of attention. Alongside the benefits it brings to buyers, such projects carry quite a few risks. One of them concerns the rules on guarantees for homes to be formed in the future.
A guarantee for homes to be formed in the future is a mandatory requirement for real estate project developers. Before such homes can be put on the market, the developer must obtain, from a commercial bank with sufficient capacity, a guarantee of the developer's financial obligations to customers in case the developer fails to hand over the homes on the schedule committed to customers. Customers therefore have the right to ask the bank to perform the obligation on the developer's behalf when the developer fails to deliver homes on time. This is a rule that benefits buyers.
In practice, however, there are many shortcomings around this arrangement, so that when problems arise, the bank does not honor the guarantee for customers:
No guarantee commitment exists between the commercial bank and the buyer of a home to be formed in the future.
A guarantee commitment is issued by the guarantor in one of two forms: a letter of guarantee or a guarantee contract. This is a written commitment or agreement from the bank to the buyer that the bank will perform the financial obligation on the investor's behalf when the investor fails to perform, or only partly performs, the obligations committed to the buyer.
In practice, commercial banks deal directly with the investor and not through the buyer. As a result, there is no guarantee commitment between the bank and the buyer, or the commitment made to the customer is merely a formality and not legally sound.
Buyers therefore need a guarantee commitment when buying a home to be formed in the future, to protect their own interests.
A guarantee commitment exists, but its clause on when the guarantee takes effect is not valid
Even when there is a guarantee commitment, its terms may be vague and not state clearly during what period the bank's guarantee obligation arises. When a problem occurs, the buyer asks the bank to honor the guarantee but is refused on the grounds that the obligation arose outside the period the parties agreed on.
The period in which the guarantee obligation arises should be clearly stipulated to avoid needless errors.
Inconsistent rules on when the guarantee ends
Clause 2, Article 56 of the Law on Real Estate Business states: “The guarantee contract is valid until the home is handed over to the buyer or lease-purchaser.”
Point e, Clause 1, Article 12 of Circular 07/2015/TT-NHNN on bank guarantees states: “A guarantee commitment for the sale or lease-purchase of homes to be formed in the future must remain valid until at least 30 days after the date the home is handed over to the buyer or lease-purchaser, as agreed between the developer and the buyer or lease-purchaser.”
This inconsistency in the legal rules works against the buyer. If the investor has handed over the home to the buyer or lease-purchaser but the home does not meet the quality committed, can the buyer still ask the bank to honor the guarantee? Therefore, in the guarantee commitment, the parties should agree specifically on how long the commitment remains valid, to avoid unnecessary disputes.
Understanding the rules on guarantees for buying homes to be formed in the future correctly and thoroughly will help buyers protect their interests and avoid unnecessary risks.