If it is established, Thủ Đức City needs to make a difference to form a dynamic urban area, a new economic locomotive not only for Ho Chi Minh City but also for the region. Therefore, the change needs both "quantity and quality," not just changing a name or adding an administrative apparatus.
A CITY OF KNOWLEDGE AND TECHNOLOGY
The proposal to establish Thủ Đức City has initially won the support of Prime Minister Nguyễn Xuân Phúc. Under it, Thủ Đức City would be established by merging the 3 eastern districts of Ho Chi Minh City: District 2, District 9 and Thủ Đức District.
This area is oriented to become a creative, highly interactive urban area, in line with the general policy of developing the digital economy and promoting capability, innovation and creativity.
Thủ Đức City is expected to have an area of 21,000 hectares and about 1 million residents, that is, about 1/10 of the area and 1/10 of the population of Ho Chi Minh City.
After it is established, Thủ Đức City is expected to help Ho Chi Minh City realize the "dream" of restructuring its economy toward knowledge, creativity and technology, which the city has not achieved in nearly two decades.
The future Thủ Đức City will be built on six key areas:
The Trường Thọ area is identified as the "heart" of the city. Here a future urban area will take shape, applying the most unique and revolutionary ideas in technology.
The Saigon Hi-Tech Park (SHTP) is oriented to become an automated manufacturing center, the home of 21st-century industry in Vietnam.
The Vietnam National University HCMC area provides a cluster of education and training together with an innovative startup center, narrowing the gap between research and application.
The Thủ Thiêm financial district has a vision of becoming the region's financial technology center.
The Rạch Chiếc area is identified as the sports and health center of Southeast Asia.
The Tam Đa area is an eco-technology center and a highly resilient urban area.
According to Associate Professor Dr. Nguyễn Minh Hòa, vice chairman of the HCMC Urban Planning and Development Association, the idea of forming Thủ Đức City is actually not new; the idea existed 10 years ago.
Splitting off the eastern part of the city would create an area focused on science, education and training. And this time too, the aim is no different, heading toward a knowledge-based, creative and technology economy.
Once formed, Thủ Đức City is expected to contribute 1/3 of Ho Chi Minh City's economy, which is about 7% of the country's GDP.
WHAT DOES THỦ ĐỨC CITY ALREADY HAVE?
Before the proposal to establish Thủ Đức City, the eastern area of Ho Chi Minh City, with the three districts of District 2, District 9 and Thủ Đức, was already one of the places with outstanding socio-economic development compared with other regions.
This area borders the dynamic economies of Đồng Nai and Bình Dương. Whereas these two localities were once seen as satellite cities of Ho Chi Minh City, they have now grown strong and become a real "counterweight" to Ho Chi Minh City.
The strong rise of Bình Dương and Đồng Nai, together with Ho Chi Minh City, specifically its eastern area, has formed a trident that drives the economic growth of the whole region.
Transport infrastructure is a standout strength of eastern Ho Chi Minh City, with a series of key infrastructure projects completed or under way.
One example is the Thủ Thiêm Tunnel, officially opened to traffic in 2011. It is the most important component of Ho Chi Minh City's East-West Avenue construction project. The tunnel is 1.49 km long, 33 m wide and 9 m high, with 6 traffic lanes, 3 on each side, for both cars and motorbikes.
In addition, the Thủ Thiêm Tunnel has 2 emergency escape lanes on either side. The design speed is 60 km/h. When it opened, the Thủ Thiêm Tunnel was the most modern in scale in Southeast Asia.
Metro Line 1 Bến Thành – Suối Tiên has a total length of 19.7 km, including 2.6 km underground and 17.1 km elevated. The line has a total of 14 stations, with 3 underground and 11 elevated, and the Long Bình depot in District 9.
The project runs through District 1, Bình Thạnh, District 2, Thủ Đức and District 9. The total planned investment for the whole line is more than ₫44,000 billion. Metro Line 1 is expected to start operating at the end of 2021.
The Ho Chi Minh City – Long Thành – Dầu Giây Expressway opened to traffic in 2015 and is more than 55 km long, starting in District 2 (Ho Chi Minh City) and ending in Thống Nhất District (Đồng Nai). The project's total investment is ₫20,630 billion. In the coming period, this expressway will be expanded to 10 lanes.
Another important transport project is Phạm Văn Đồng Avenue, with a total length of nearly 14 km, running from Trường Sơn Interchange (Tân Sơn Nhất Airport) to National Highway 1A, with a road surface 30–65 m wide (equivalent to 6–12 lanes).
The road connects Tân Sơn Nhất Airport to National Highway 1A and National Highway 1K, passing through Tân Bình, Gò Vấp, Bình Thạnh and Thủ Đức districts and the two provinces of Bình Dương and Đồng Nai.
Besides transport infrastructure, the areas regarded as the "core" of the future Thủ Đức City are also now gradually taking shape. Among them, the Thủ Thiêm Urban Area covers 657 ha, including a commercial and financial center and residential areas for about 150,000 residents and more than 220,000 regular workers.
The hi-tech park in District 9 has also welcomed many big names in the world's technology industry, such as Samsung and Intel. The Vietnam National University HCMC, with a system of more than 10 member schools, trains tens of thousands of students each year.
In real estate, eastern Ho Chi Minh City is seen as a golden land that every developer covets. The large-scale urban areas that have sprung up and are rising contribute greatly to changing the face of many areas here.
Some large projects include Vinhomes Grand Park by Vingroup, under construction in District 9 on 272 ha; the Vạn Phúc City mega-urban project of 198 ha in Thủ Đức District by Đại Phúc Group; the Sala urban area in Thủ Thiêm by Đại Quang Minh, covering more than 100 ha; and the Nam Rạch Chiếc residential area by NovaLand Group in District 2, covering more than 30 ha…
WHERE WILL THE MONEY TO BUILD THỦ ĐỨC CITY COME FROM?
The proposal to establish Thủ Đức City has the agreement and support of many experts. However, there are still many obstacles on the road to making it a reality.
At a discussion recently organized by the Saigon Giải Phóng newspaper on the theme "Necessary and sufficient conditions to realize Thủ Đức City, the creative city: advantages, challenges and roadmap," many experts raised questions that need answers. The one of greatest concern is where the money to build Thủ Đức City will come from.
According to Dr. Võ Kim Cương, former deputy chief architect of Ho Chi Minh City, the potential for development and the investment value of newly developed urban areas around the world are very large. And here the biggest challenge for us is where the money and funding to do it will come from. In urban principles, a city is born from land, that is, by exploiting the land fund and gradually building up infrastructure. But land in this area is currently subject to speculation, and how to exploit it is a challenge.
Mr. Cương believes that the city's infrastructure investment funding should be allocated per square meter of land, with each square meter obliged to contribute to construction. Every landowner must contribute, rather than the state paying for everything.
Professor Trần Ngọc Thơ, a member of the National Financial and Monetary Policy Advisory Council, asks whether the current thinking of raising capital from the land fund is right at all. After all, the land fund is always finite, while financial resources and creative ideas are endless and are always opportunities that can be created continuously.
Therefore, the thinking needs to be the opposite, that is, it should start from policies that create the highest world-class environment, with law being an independent judicial law, a convertible currency, or at least a special economic zone and a special financial zone that allow foreign capital to flow in and out freely… These things will create financial resources, rather than only thinking of the land fund to find capital in the traditional way.
Besides the financial capacity to build Thủ Đức City, legal regulations need to clarify what the status of "a city within a city" will be. How will the new city differ from the remaining districts of Ho Chi Minh City, and from cities in other localities? What will the administrative apparatus be like, and will the city be managed by Ho Chi Minh City or by the central government?
BEWARE OF SPECULATION AND REAL ESTATE PRICE INFLATION
Observations show that as soon as the idea of establishing an eastern city appeared, the area became an indispensable "highlight" in many advertising campaigns and product presentations of real estate projects.
Now, house and land prices in District 2, Thủ Đức and District 9, which were already high, have even more excuse to rise further.
According to statistics from a market research firm, over the past three years apartment prices in the eastern area have risen by about 50–80%. In particular, projects in the Thủ Thiêm area have seen prices rise nearly twofold in 3 years, from US$2,700–3,500/m² to US$6,000–8,000/m². In the low-rise segment, land prices have risen by 50–250% depending on the area.
The general director of a real estate company in Ho Chi Minh City said that establishing the eastern city is a sound policy to mobilize domestic and foreign resources to build a model urban area.
The new city must have specific mechanisms and policies to create favorable conditions to attract investing businesses. If it goes in the right direction, all sectors will benefit and be part of that development. Real estate in this area will gain real value.
However, if it goes "off course," it will leave many consequences, and real estate is the sector that will be hit hardest. In reality, there are already many new urban areas and cities established decades ago that set off several land fevers but still have not taken shape to this day, and are even called "ghost cities."
In addition, planning information like this, if not managed and communicated transparently, can easily be exploited by interest groups and speculators as a juicy bait to create waves of house and land price rises, destabilizing the real estate market.
Dr. Sử Ngọc Khương, senior director of Savills Vietnam, said that a new city only truly delivers results when it has special planning, attractive policies inviting domestic and foreign investment, and a good technical and social infrastructure foundation… so that it becomes a "counterbalance" to the existing city center.
Conversely, if only the name "city" is changed, only the image will be addressed. Meanwhile, having an additional leadership apparatus will make administrative costs even higher, and residents will have difficulty having to change their papers and information.
Mr. Lê Hoàng Châu, chairman of the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA), said that the proposal for a city within a city is a sound policy, but if it is not well controlled it will be an excuse for speculation, price inflation and rampant plot subdivision and land sales in this area. This is also a major challenge for the planning of Thủ Đức City.
According to Mr. Châu, the city government needs solutions to create opportunities so that long-time residents of these districts benefit first, so they do not sell too early. At the same time, it should create opportunities such as a large land fund to welcome major investors in order to develop synchronized projects with the potential to help drive the overall development of the new city.
In particular, the city needs to announce planning information quickly, fully, in detail and publicly so that all residents know clearly, thereby limiting speculation and artificial fevers in the real estate market.
Source: Cafeland