Land prices have jumped 2–3 times and materials and labor have risen another 30–40% in the past 5 years, making affordable housing vanish from the inventory.
Over the past 9 months, almost all housing projects in the districts and outlying areas of Saigon have seen apartment prices gradually approach ₫35–37 million per m². As a result, 45–50 m² apartments, which used to be the cheapest ₫1 billion homes on the market, have jumped to ₫1.6–1.7 billion each, that is, ₫500–700 million more than in 2015–2016. Experts say there are at least 5 reasons why affordable apartments in Ho Chi Minh City are now more expensive than before.
Land prices have jumped 2–3 times in half a decade
Having developed affordable housing on the edge of Saigon for more than a decade, Mr. Lê Hữu Nghĩa, director of Lê Thành Company, said the first factor making apartments priced under ₫25 million per m² (a 45 m² apartment priced at ₫1.1 billion) of half a decade ago gradually disappear from the market is that land prices keep rising. Taking the period from 2015–2016 to now, it is not hard to see that 2016 was the start of the land fevers, and these price increases continued until the first half of 2018 before cooling down for a while.
According to Mr. Nghĩa, over the past half decade land prices have jumped 2–3 times depending on location. Land accounts for 30–35% of the total input costs that make up an apartment, so the steep rise in land prices in earlier years left a heavy legacy for later years, pushing affordable housing prices higher. Today, finding a 45–50 m² apartment priced at ₫1 billion within Ho Chi Minh City has become impossible.
Materials and labor costs up 30–40%
Mr. Nghĩa went on to analyze that, besides land prices that are now far too high, construction material and labor prices have also fluctuated sharply over the past 5 years. Specifically, the input prices of materials for building housing in 2020 had risen by an average of 30% compared with 2015.
Meanwhile, half a decade ago skilled construction workers were paid ₫300,000 a day, but now they must be paid at least ₫450,000 a day to make ends meet. The cause is the hard, heavy nature of the work, which is only seasonal, at a time of rising living costs.
With material and labor prices rising 30–40% after 5 years, plus land prices rising out of control, businesses that build affordable housing have been forced to raise product costs to make up for these expenses, so the inventory of affordable apartments cannot hold its old prices.
Legal obstacles push housing prices up
In many recent reports, the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA) has repeatedly warned that legal procedure bottlenecks are inflating the cost of housing projects. HoREA said that from October 2015 to the end of 2020, Saigon had no fewer than a hundred commercial housing projects with mixed-use land funds whose investment and construction procedures were stuck, or whose land came from State-managed land funds and needed a legal review.
In particular, in some cases the projects had to be inspected or investigated. This situation kept projects delayed in legal procedures in 2019–2020, and this legal risk is weighing on the housing market.
In addition, many housing projects have not had a decision on collecting land use fees issued by the Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee, because of difficulties over how to calculate for public land plots wedged inside projects and over the methods of determining land prices. As a result, developers cannot pay land use fees into the state budget.
This is also why projects do not meet the conditions to raise capital from customers, which increases business costs, especially financial costs, and thereby raises housing selling prices. What is worrying is that these legal risks build up gradually, and in the end home buyers have to bear them in ever higher selling prices.
Unpredictable consequences of scarce supply
Mr. Lê Hoàng Châu, chairman of HoREA, said that because many housing projects are delayed in legal procedures, housing supply has become scarce, giving the projects now on offer the chance to push house prices up. The number of housing projects in Ho Chi Minh City has fallen since 2017, down by 85% in 2019, and 2020 became even quieter because of Covid-19. The association warned that the slowdown in housing supply in the country's most dynamic market is at an alarming level, and the supply shortage pushes house prices up even further.
According to Mr. Châu, the price inflation at first occurred only in the luxury and high-end segments in the core center of Ho Chi Minh City. Later, however, the price hikes spread to the mid-to-high-end segments, and even to affordable housing in districts adjacent or close to the center, and finally reached the edge of Saigon. This development pushed the price level of affordable apartments higher than in previous years.
Businesses are not keen on building affordable housing
Mr. Nguyễn Lộc Hạnh, general director of Ngọc Châu Á Real Estate Investment Joint Stock Company, said that low profit margins combined with high legal risks, prolonged procedures and ever-harder land bank creation have made businesses lose interest in building affordable housing.
Mr. Hạnh said that over the past 3 years, affordable apartments have made up only 21.81% of all housing in projects. This ratio is very low compared with mid-to-high-end apartments (78.19%). The growing mismatch of supply and demand between the high-end and affordable housing segments is proof that businesses are gradually withdrawing from the affordable housing market.
When input pressures are too great, the effort and capital spent building affordable, low-priced housing begin to approach those of the mid-range segments. This forces businesses to choose higher-priced housing segments to offset ever-larger costs. The ₫1 billion apartment threshold may no longer suit commercial housing from 2020 onward.
Via VnExpress