More than a hundred real estate technology (proptech) startups in Vietnam are struggling to survive in a turbulent, highly local real estate market.
After about seven years in the market, in mid-September 2022, Propzy, the startup that had announced US$37 million in funding, the largest among Vietnam's real estate technology (proptech) companies, said it was shutting down. Only a short time earlier, several reports had described the startup as having the potential to become a tech unicorn. It gave running out of money as the reason for closing. Community attention on Vietnam's proptech sector has now turned to two names, Homebase and Rever, which announced funding of US$30 million and US$16.5 million respectively, ranking second and third in the market after Propzy.
The reason is that real estate technology is a new field that is still burning cash, and even the best-funded startups may be weeded out if they move too early. Which name will survive until dawn? “We haven't seen much change in the Vietnamese proptech market in the past three years,” said Ms. Đỗ Hà Phương, senior investment director at Jafco Asia, a venture capital fund focused on the Asia-Pacific region. According to Ms. Phương, most of the proptech models now in Vietnam have already been deployed in Indonesia and Singapore, and there are not many standout companies. At the same time, the COVID-19 pandemic has kept the real estate industry stagnant since 2020, while the capital market is in a “hibernation” phase. These developments are forcing proptech companies to change, slim down their models and focus on creating a stable cash flow to reach break-even instead of continuing to burn cash as before. “Investor confidence in the Vietnamese proptech market was already tough, and now they are even more cautious about putting money in,” Ms. Phương said.
Rever was founded in 2016, six years after founder Phan Lê Mạnh bought his first home. Messy property information, brokers who did not have a grasp of available inventory, and cumbersome procedures were the experiences Mạnh went through in 2010 that pushed him to leave his job at VNG and found Rever (meaning “dream” in French), believing that technology would help brokers work more efficiently. According to the company's own information, Rever has more than 98,000 properties with verified information on its system, and about 300 full-time brokers among its 400 employees.
After six years of experience with the market, Mạnh believes brokers find it hard to stay in the profession, partly because they lack accurate information and tools to connect with customers. “For every ten people who come in, eight leave because of low productivity,” Mạnh said. Focusing on brokerage, the tools Rever offers are expected to help brokers increase their number of transactions and improve their professionalism through training courses. Speaking to Forbes Vietnam, Mạnh said that on average, a Rever broker completes about four transactions a year worth ₫3–4 billion each. However, the real estate market is now correcting sharply and limited supply is hurting their business results. Focusing on its main market, Ho Chi Minh City, Mạnh said Rever's revenue so far this year has “not grown” compared with the same period last year. The startup's fundraising plan has also been delayed, and Rever may not break even until the end of 2023.
Vietnam's real estate market is estimated to reach more than US$1.23 trillion, accounting for 22% of the economy's total assets by 2030. This high-value product suffers from cumbersome systems and procedures, so liquidity is low. Project information is scattered and distorted, while the legal framework for transactions still has many gaps. These characteristics appear in all three groups of real estate transactions: renting/buying/selling, lending and investing. But the very problems occurring in the market are an opportunity for proptech companies to step in and solve them.
Going back about ten years, that was when Vietnam's first generation of proptech companies was founded, most of them classified-ad portals. Searching for information is the user's first touchpoint before they need two other important links in the home buying and selling journey: support from a broker and finding a loan. Since the Law on Real Estate Business was introduced in 2007, portals such as Batdongsan, Muabannhadat and Diaoconline appeared one after another and gradually changed the experience of people making transactions. Today, most of Vietnam's early proptech companies have left the race, giving way to two Singaporean unicorns: Batdongsan.com.vn (PropertyGuru) and Chợ Tốt Nhà (Carousell).
The pioneer was Batdongsan.com.vn, part of Đại Việt Group and founded by Mr. Lê Xuân Trường, launched in 2008 to help users find property information more easily. Ten years later, PropertyGuru acquired the site. Mr. Trường continued in his management role until Mr. Robert Vũ was appointed to replace him in 2020. According to PropertyGuru's 2022 half-year financial report, Batdongsan.com.vn accounts for 75% of the online engagement share among real estate information channels in Vietnam, three times that of the second-placed rival.
In the first half of this year, the Vietnam market (including Batdongsan.com.vn and Dothi.net) brought in revenue of nearly S$12 million (about US$8.5 million). Mr. Lê Bảo Long, strategy director of Batdongsan.com.vn, said the channel now has about 800 full-time employees, more than 70 million page views and one million listings every month.
The results of their surveys show that technology currently creates the most value in searching for information, and has not yet changed much in users' journey of buying, selling and managing property. “Real estate is a traditional industry and is highly local. Users need time to get used to and adapt to most of the applied technologies launched recently, such as loan provision,” Mr. Long said. The runner-up to Batdongsan.com.vn among real estate information sites is considered to be Chợ Tốt Nhà (part of Chợ Tốt). This second-hand classified-ad site moved into real estate in 2017 by opening Chợ Tốt Nhà, a dedicated site for buying, selling and renting property.
Ms. Trần Nguyễn Hoàng Uyên, head of Chợ Tốt's real estate division, said the company has about 40 staff in charge of building the dedicated real estate site. They apply automatic listing review technology, ensuring that listings are checked and approved within 30 minutes. The site now has nearly 10 million visits a month and about 600,000 listings on the system. In 2023, Chợ Tốt Nhà will focus on property sales and provide tools to help brokers boost their sales performance.
After more than a decade, Vietnam's first generation of proptech has gone through a shake-out. However, the market-leading companies in this model still face the same challenge as when they entered the market: removing fake information. Meanwhile, a second generation of proptech has emerged, including traditional companies. The second generation can be divided into two groups.
The first group is traditional real estate businesses that invest in proptech to increase the liquidity of their in-house products, such as TopenLand and PropertyX of Hưng Thịnh, CenHomes of CenLand, or OneHousing of One Mount Real Estate, a member of One Mount Group. This group has the advantages of capital, inventory, reputation and market experience, and can make use of many pieces of the ecosystem.
The remaining proptech group operates independently, aims to solve niche problems in the market, and mostly chooses to be platforms that connect and support brokers, with names such as Propzy, Rever and Houze Agent. According to estimates by Nextrans and the Vietnam Proptech Network, there are currently about 150 startups in the proptech field.
Looking at the map of hundreds of proptech companies on the market, Mr. Phạm Lâm, chairman of DKRA Group, assessed that only about five companies have a clear strategy and outstanding scale. “Very few companies both understand the local characteristics of the real estate industry and have a technology team that builds compatible products,” he said.
DKRA Group is a case of a traditional brokerage company entering proptech through the startup Houze. It provides a broker-connecting platform serving the primary market in order to survive, while looking for ways to gain a foothold in the secondary market. Drawing on about 18 years of experience in real estate and while running DKRA Vietnam, Mr. Lâm and his team founded Houze in 2020.
Houze's revenue comes from three sources. Ranked by contribution to revenue, brokerage services (Houze Agent) come first, followed by a multi-utility integrated platform offered to apartment building management units (Houze Commerce) and a fractional property investment platform (Houze Invest).
Speaking to Forbes Vietnam, Mr. Lâm said that from 2021 to September 2022, Houze recorded nearly ₫45 billion in revenue from brokerage fees, which is “still small compared with traditional brokerage companies.” Meanwhile, Houze Commerce currently serves the management units of 45 apartment buildings, with revenue of only “two hundred million dong a month,” but the data on transactions across nearly 37,000 apartments is valuable for Houze when it enters the secondary market in the future.
The primary market in Vietnam brings in large revenue, while the secondary market needs more time and costs a lot to build data. Proptech companies estimate that the average brokerage fee per primary property worth ₫3 billion in Vietnam is about 3%, and about 1% for the secondary market. This high fee helps keep startups alive but also poses many challenges. “Developers need a partner that can sell, not a sales company that applies technology. That means they need efficiency and safety when choosing a distribution partner,” Mr. Lâm said.
Technology will help collect data, which is the key for proptech companies to tap the market. Trần Minh Long, a Forbes Vietnam Under 30 honoree in 2018, founded Citics four years ago, after eight years in the real estate field.
However, Long chose not to serve the force of more than 300,000 brokers. This is partly because standards for this group have not yet been tightened, with only about 10% of brokers holding a practicing certificate. Citics chose to build its data by providing valuation services based on technology and data.
A consumer searches for real estate information on a proptech platform (stock photo).
Long said that about 70% of collateral in banks is real estate. However, traditional valuation companies that serve bank mortgage lending all follow manual processes that depend on a group of people, take a long time and are not very accurate.
Under the traditional method, the valuation process takes about three days per property. Meanwhile, 90% of the valuation process carried out by Citics is done through digital tools, and the rest is handled by staff on site. They need 1–3 hours to complete an online valuation report that banks accept.
“This service is only the starting point in the ecosystem of services around real estate and banking that Citics is building,” Trần Minh Long said.
According to its own figures, Citics is a valuation service partner for 20 banks, with 23 million properties valued on its system. With US$3 million raised so far and revenue growing 3–5 times a year, the startup expects to break even by the end of this year. Long said Citics will raise a Series A round in 2023 to develop new services and will keep focusing on serving banks.
Taking a different approach, in the capital-support link of the chain, Homebase and FINA serve property buyers directly. While Homebase supports customers with “buy now, pay gradually,” FINA aims to be a personal financial advisory platform that connects customers with financial institutions.
Based on credit scores, FINA calculates and guides customers on where to borrow and how much is suitable, so that total debt payments do not exceed 30% of total income, to ensure financial safety. Mr. Phạm Anh Khôi, founder of FINA, said loan volume through the platform over the past two years was about ₫4,000 billion, with an average loan of ₫1.5 billion. Two years after its founding, FINA is looking to cooperate with businesses that already have an ecosystem to secure cash flow at a time when raising capital is difficult, as it is now.
In 2021, total capital flowing into Vietnam's startup ecosystem was more than US$1.4 billion, but only US$29 million went into proptech and infrastructure. Rising interest rates have eroded confidence in proptech investments in many developed countries. The domestic real estate market is complex, governed by distinct legal characteristics and varying tastes between regions, which makes investment funds cautious about disbursing money. Meanwhile, foreign proptech companies are still watching and looking for opportunities to enter the market, not ruling out mergers and acquisitions.
“Having reached a position of competing head-on with PropertyGuru in Singapore and dominating the business in the Indonesian market, 99 Group sees huge potential in Vietnam and is actively studying the market,” said Mr. Chong Ming Hwee, co-founder and chief executive of New Markets (part of 99 Group), during a recent business trip to meet several proptech companies in Vietnam.
From the print edition of Forbes Vietnam issue 111, November 2022, special feature “Decoding project developers.”
Source: Forbes Vietnam