In just the first eight months of 2019, the total value of corporate bonds issued rose above ₫140,000 billion, almost as much as in all of 2018. Real estate and construction companies accounted for a fairly large share of that. Bond interest rates were also at their highest, reaching 14.5%. So why are real estate companies rushing into the race to issue bonds?
Real estate companies are starved of capital
Real estate companies are starved of capital
According to the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA), in the first six months of 2019 the Department of Construction proposed that the city People's Committee recognize investors for only three new commercial housing projects, down 84.2% from the same period in 2018. The department also proposed that the People's Committee approve investment in 10 commercial housing projects, down 82.2% from the same period in 2018. These figures show that the Ho Chi Minh City market is going through an extremely difficult period.
HoREA Chairman Lê Hoàng Châu said that more than 150 projects in Ho Chi Minh City have been reviewed or inspected in recent times. Although most projects have now resumed normal operations, the impact of those reviews is still very large. Recently, a series of Ho Chi Minh City officials have been caught up in legal trouble related to land, which has seriously affected project implementation. As a result, many projects by real estate "tycoons" that involve public land have had to halt construction.
In addition, after several years of explosive growth, the real estate market has slowed down. Housing and land prices in Ho Chi Minh City are now very high, which has made speculators hesitate, while most people who genuinely need a home cannot "reach" those prices. So even when a project has completed its legal paperwork, selling is not at all easy for many real estate companies.
The consequence is that many real estate companies have fallen into difficulty. Hundreds of thousands of billions of dong have been poured into projects that cannot move forward and cannot be sold. Against this background, many real estate companies have lost liquidity, and cash flow from their business operations has fallen short.
The clearest evidence is that many real estate companies have large shortfalls in operating cash flow. For example, Đất Xanh Group Joint Stock Company recorded negative operating cash flow of ₫653 billion in the first six months of the year, compared with negative ₫996 billion in the same period last year.
Similarly, Phát Đạt Real Estate (PDR) recorded negative operating cash flow of ₫1,337 billion in the first six months of 2019, compared with negative ₫618 billion in the same period last year. Another major real estate company, Văn Phú Invest, saw its operating cash flow reach negative ₫1,527 billion in the six months, compared with negative ₫418 billion in the same period last year.
Getting around credit barriers?
Many real estate companies are "starved of capital," but borrowing from banks is not easy either. The reason is that banks are now very cautious about lending to real estate companies, because the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) may soon raise the risk weight on real estate loans from the current 200% to 250%. Under that rule, if a bank lends heavily to real estate, its capital adequacy ratio (CAR) will fall below the SBV's minimum of 9%, or below the Basel II standard.
Lending capacity is also limited because, under Circular 19/2017/TT-NHNN, the ratio of short-term funds that can be used for medium- and long-term loans has been cut from 45% to 40%. This cut forces banks to think carefully about lending to projects that carry many risks at this stage.
Another important factor is that many real estate companies would find it hard to "explain" transparently how they use borrowed money, because in practice quite a few of them have to raise new funds to repay old debts. Once projects are "frozen" by inspections, or the real estate market runs into difficulty, cash flow from business operations can hardly repay debts as they fall due. Companies therefore inevitably have to roll over their debts to avoid bad loans, and banks find it very hard to lend them money to "roll over debt."
Beyond the reasons above, bank lending also faces obstacles because of the cap on credit growth.
Specifically, at the start of 2019 the SBV set the credit growth target for the year at 14%. As a result, many banks were given a fairly low credit "room" and could not expand lending too aggressively. Recently some banks have been able to "breathe more easily" as the SBV opened up more "room." For example, VPBank's credit growth target was raised from 12% to 16%; Techcombank's from 13% to 17%; MB's from 13% to 17%; and ACB's from 13% to 17%.
For these reasons, both banks and companies "prefer" bonds to credit. When banks buy bonds, they are not subject to the strict conditions that apply to lending. For companies, raising money through bonds in many cases requires no collateral account, the funds are "disbursed" immediately, and there are no strict conditions on how the money is used, unlike with bank credit. The capital can therefore be used for many different purposes.
The bank currently "holding" the most bonds is Techcombank. According to its financial statements, at the end of June 2019 Techcombank's total investment in corporate bonds was more than ₫60,000 billion. Most of the bonds Techcombank invests in are held through its subsidiary, Techcom Securities. The bonds Techcombank holds most are tied to groups such as Vingroup and Sun Group. Most recently, for example, Techcombank bought ₫740 billion of 7-year bonds at an interest rate of 10.3% from Bà Nà Cable Car Services Joint Stock Company.
Other banks with large bond holdings are SHB with ₫24,000 billion and BIDV with ₫22,600 billion. A sizable portion of BIDV's bond investment (more than ₫6,000 billion) consists of Hoàng Anh Gia Lai's debt restructuring bonds. Other banks with relatively large corporate bond holdings are Vietinbank at about ₫18,900 billion and Military Bank (MB) at ₫15,000 billion.
Companies that have had to issue bonds because of operating cash flow shortfalls include Phát Đạt Real Estate (PDR). In the first six months of the year, PDR issued bonds three times: a ₫200 billion issue of 1-year bonds in March at an interest rate as high as 14.5%, and two issues in May of ₫100 billion of 1-year bonds at 12% and ₫550 billion of 5-year bonds at 10.5%. Văn Phú Invest (VPI) issued ₫1,000 billion, and Khang Điền Home Business (KDH) issued ₫900 billion, both at 12%.
Source: Nhịp sống kinh tế