According to the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA), it is necessary to firmly stop and deal with organizations and individuals who subdivide agricultural and forest land on their own to illegally build tourist accommodation facilities and illegally sell or raise capital through “farmstay” plots to secondary investors.
According to HoREA, in the past few years some agricultural farms have combined farming with running a “tourist accommodation facility” under a “rural experience tourist area – farmstay” model, so that tourists can stay and experience rural production and daily life (similar to running a “house with rooms for tourists to rent – homestay”).
If it is a “rural experience tourist area – farmstay project” approved by the competent state agency and operating as a tourism business, that is perfectly normal.
But if organizations or individuals subdivide agricultural or forest land on their own to illegally build tourist accommodation facilities and run “farmstay” tourism businesses without the project being approved by the competent state agency and without converting the land use purpose to commercial or service land, they must be corrected and dealt with promptly.
In particular, according to HoREA, it is necessary to firmly stop and deal with organizations and individuals who subdivide agricultural and forest land on their own to illegally build tourist accommodation facilities and illegally sell or raise capital through “farmstay” plots to secondary investors.
“However, the “rural experience tourist area – farmstay” project type is a new demand of the tourism market and the tourism real estate market, so it is very necessary to build a legal framework to regulate it and ensure healthy and sustainable development,” stressed Mr. Lê Hoàng Châu, Chairman of HoREA.
As for the cause of the spontaneous growth of the “farmstay” business model, HoREA says it may stem from documents below the level of the Land Law. Specifically, Articles 143 and 144 of the Land Law provide only for splitting plots of “rural residential land” and “urban residential land.” But Clause 31, Article 2 of Decree 01/2017/ND-CP, which added Article 43d to Decree 43/2014/ND-CP, allows plots to be split for each type of land (Article 43d. Regulations on the minimum area for splitting a plot: Provincial People's Committees set the minimum area allowed for splitting a plot for each type of land to suit local conditions).
These provisions are inconsistent with Articles 143 and 144 of the Land Law, because they allow plots to be split even for types of land that are not “residential land,” which may increase widespread plot subdivision and sale of land plots, or the splitting of agricultural and forest land that is hard to control.
Next, according to HoREA, another cause may be local governments loosening their management of the “farmstay” business model run by some businesses in their areas.
Or the cause may be the “farmstay” investment and business activities of some organizations and individuals that do not comply with the law.
Given this situation, HoREA recommends that the Government direct strict implementation of Articles 143 and 144 of the Land Law, allowing plots to be split only for “rural residential land” and “urban residential land,” and not allowing plots to be split for types of land that are not “residential land.”
For other types of land interspersed in urban areas and rural residential clusters, where land users want to split plots to build houses, they must first carry out the procedure to convert the land use purpose to “residential land,” and only then carry out the procedure to split the “residential land” plot as required.
Businesses that want to convert agricultural or forest land to commercial or service land to carry out investment projects, including “farmstay” projects, must prepare an “investment project” in accordance with the laws on investment, real estate business and tourism, consistent with zoning plans and subject to review and approval by the competent state agency.
At the same time, the HCMC Real Estate Association also asked the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism to consider proposing that a (new) type of tourist accommodation facility, the “rural experience tourist area – farmstay,” be added to Article 48 of the Law on Tourism for unified management, and to amend Decision 3720/QD-BVHTTDL dated October 28, 2019 of the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism to add a management and operation mechanism for the “farmstay” model.
According to Tri thức trẻ