The terms mixed-use land and new residential development land appear in hundreds of 1:2000 zoning plans in Ho Chi Minh City but are not found in the relevant legal documents.
Districts have run into many obstacles in handling land and construction files related to mixed-use land (ĐHH) and new residential development land (DCXDM). However, after reviewing the relevant regulations, we found that the Land Law only provides for agricultural and non-agricultural land, and the Law on Urban Planning does not contain these terms either.
Appearing in 600 zoning plans
According to Document 3272/2018 of the Department of Planning and Architecture on resolving obstacles in construction and land procedures for areas zoned for mixed-use land and new residential development land, both zoning functions appear in 600 1:2000 zoning plans approved across the city. Of these, mixed-use land alone is concentrated mainly in 310 plans drawn up, appraised and approved by the city People's Committee from 2013 to now.
Speaking to Ho Chi Minh City Law newspaper, many districts said that when drawing up new or adjusting 1:2000 zoning plans, the term new residential development land does not appear in the relevant legal provisions. Yet nearly 12,500 ha across the city are zoned for the function of new residential development land.
Mixed-use land alone is mentioned in the Vietnam Building Code (QCXDVN) 01:2008, whose glossary states: a mixed-use building (or land) is a building (or land fund) used for several different purposes (for example, housing combined with commercial services and/or production…).
Under the QCXDVN, a 1:2000 detailed urban construction plan must propose land-use planning solutions that meet the requirements for mixed-use land, ensuring a flexible and dynamic response to the city's development needs, including the types of functions (one or several) permitted on each plot. It also specifies areas for mixed-use buildings including housing, administration, services and non-hazardous production…
In fact, today's 1:2000 zoning plans only give the percentage of each type of land within mixed-use zoning but do not specify where each group is located. As a result, districts have no basis to handle land-purpose changes, plot splitting and formal construction permits for residents.
According to the Department of Natural Resources and Environment, the Land Law currently provides only for the agricultural and non-agricultural land groups and has neither mixed-use land nor new residential development land.
Prolonged obstacles with no way out yet
In meetings between City People's Council delegates and voters, residents have repeatedly voiced frustration over being unable to change land purpose or split plots, and being given only time-limited construction permits in these zones.
According to the City People's Council's Urban Affairs Committee, in 2017 the City People's Council issued Resolution 21 on managing urban zoning and resolving delayed projects in the city. In it, the City People's Council assigned the City People's Committee to focus on resolving obstacles in construction and land procedures, safeguarding the lawful rights and interests of residents with houses and land in areas zoned for mixed-use land and new residential development land.
A “hotpot” of mixed-use land
Today's 1:2000 zoning plans only give the percentage of each type of land within mixed-use zoning but say they cannot specify where each group is located. As a result, districts have no basis to handle land-purpose changes, plot splitting and formal construction permits for residents.
In April 2018, the City People's Council held an explanatory session on resolving the difficulties and obstacles above. After that session, the Department of Planning and Architecture issued Official Letter 3272 guiding districts on implementation, as we have reported. However, the situation has not changed much: residents are still frustrated and districts are still confused.
In August 2019, the Urban Affairs Committee again held surveys in Districts 3 and 9 and in Hóc Môn and Bình Chánh Districts on the results of implementation after the 2018 session.
According to the Urban Affairs Committee, since 2018 the City People's Committee has issued documents directing the Departments of Planning and Architecture, Natural Resources and Environment, and Construction to guide districts in resolving issues related to plot splitting and construction permits in mixed-use and new residential development zoning. However, the departments have been slow and inconsistent in carrying out this direction, and there has been no close coordination among the specialized agencies to advise the city on settling these obstacles for good.
“Although districts and the Department of Planning and Architecture have made many efforts to review and plan and have proposed some solutions to remove the obstacles, the solutions proposed by the Department of Planning and Architecture differ from the districts' views, with no set implementation time or specific measures. Some solutions are not feasible and need a lot of time, making it hard to quickly settle the rights of residents in these zoned areas,” the Urban Affairs Committee said in a survey report.
No common guidance yet
Recently, in a document commenting on a report to the Department of Document Inspection (Ministry of Justice) on the City People's Committee's Decision 60/2017 on the minimum area allowed for plot splitting, the Department of Justice also reviewed the relevant legal provisions on these two zoning functions.
Specifically: the 2013 Land Law, the Urban Planning Laws of 2009 and 2017, the Government's decrees on construction planning and urban planning, and the City's general Regulation on management of urban architectural planning issued with the City People's Committee's Decision 29/2014. “The Department of Justice finds that these documents do not use the terms ‘new construction zoning’ or ‘mixed-use zoning’, nor do they explain these types of zoning,” the Department of Justice said.
In addition, the Department of Justice also holds that the 2013 Land Law only gives provincial People's Committees the authority to set the minimum area for plot splitting for two types of land, rural residential land and urban residential land, and does not give authority to set a minimum splitting area for other types of land. Therefore, the City People's Committee's Decision 60/2017 on the minimum splitting area, which provides that mixed-use land and new residential development land cannot be split, “restricts residents' right to split land plots.”
In practice, obstacles related to mixed-use and new residential development zoning leave districts very confused, and they regularly send documents to the Departments of Planning and Architecture, Natural Resources and Environment, and Construction asking for guidance, as Districts 9, 12, Bình Thạnh and Bình Tân and Hóc Môn and Bình Chánh Districts have done… To date, besides Document 3272, which still has many shortcomings, the Departments of Construction, Natural Resources and Environment, and Planning and Architecture have not issued a common guiding document for all 24 districts to implement consistently and resolve these obstacles.
Source: Việt Hoa (Ho Chi Minh City Law)