The association believes plot subdivision and land sales must be managed and controlled effectively so that urban development follows the plan and avoids spontaneous “oil-spill” sprawl.
The HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA) has sent a document to the Prime Minister and the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment on the draft “Decree amending and supplementing a number of Decrees implementing the Land Law.”
Clause 17, Article 1 of the draft Decree amends and supplements Clause 2, Article 41 of Decree 43/2014/ND-CP to state: “Developers of housing construction and business projects for sale, or for sale combined with rental, may, based on the list of works and projects in the district-level annual land use plan approved by the provincial People's Council and the provincial People's Committee, which identifies the cases allowed to transfer land use rights in the form of plot subdivision and land sales, do so only in areas outside centrally governed cities, provincial cities and the planned functional areas of centrally governed cities and provincial cities, the inner-city districts of special-class urban areas; areas with high requirements for architectural landscape, central areas and the surroundings of works that are architectural highlights in the city; and the street frontages of regional-level and higher roads and the main landscape roads in the city.”
HoREA argues that under this provision, housing projects in the form of plot subdivision and land sales would be banned throughout the territory of centrally governed cities, provincial cities and the planned functional areas of centrally governed cities and provincial cities, including inner-city districts; wards and towns under cities, towns, urban and rural districts; and even rural districts and communes.
The association believes that the proposal to ban plot subdivision and land sales outright “in areas outside centrally governed cities, provincial cities and the planned functional areas of centrally governed cities and provincial cities” neither conforms to current law nor protects land users' right to split urban or rural residential land plots, nor meets the demand for landed housing and home buyers' financial means.
“However, the association also sees the need for the State to manage and control plot subdivision and land sales effectively, to ensure the principle of economical and efficient land use, especially for urban land, so that urban development follows the plan and avoids spontaneous, low-rise ‘oil-spill’ sprawl, which both wastes land funds and makes it hard to connect urban infrastructure,” HoREA said.
The association said that, based on legal provisions and on practical demand for landed housing, where buyers purchase a plot and build their own homes in line with their finances, it proposes banning “plot subdivision and land sales” projects only in inner-city districts, areas with high requirements for architectural landscape, central areas and the surroundings of architectural highlights in the city, and the street frontages of regional-level and higher roads and the main landscape roads in the city, as Clause 2, Article 41 of Decree 43/2014/ND-CP already provides. In districts and communes in the rural outskirts of the special-class urban areas, namely Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City, some “plot subdivision and land sales” projects should still be allowed if they fit the urban development plan and local conditions.
Moreover, HoREA argues that Articles 143 and 144 of the Land Law allow splitting of rural and urban residential land plots, which will certainly create a supply of land plots for the market, including in urban areas. Therefore, at present it is appropriate to restrict and control “plot subdivision and land sales” projects only in the two special-class urban areas, and there is no need to extend the scope to other centrally governed cities or to provincial cities and towns, which should be left for local authorities to consider and decide.
Source: Bizlive