Under the same legal system, many real estate projects used to be signed off and approved, yet now sit idle because of investment procedure bottlenecks.
Affirming that regulators are right to be cautious in approving projects and that the law cannot be applied carelessly, Professor and Doctor of Science Đặng Hùng Võ, former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment, argues that the Land Law has many shortcomings that must be fixed immediately, and that real estate projects cannot be left “shelved” because of conflicting regulations that lag behind market development.
From legal bottlenecks to a supply crisis
A very hot issue in the real estate market today is that a large number of projects are stuck in legal procedures. As someone who has studied law for many years, what do you think businesses are most stuck on in land procedures?
Prof. Đặng Hùng Võ: In fact, since 2019 the number of projects in the real estate market has fallen about 10-fold compared with the previous year. Many businesses had prepared to invest and put huge sums into projects, but still have to wait because they are not approved.
On this issue, since 2018 the Prime Minister has required ministries and sectors to amend the laws related to the real estate market to remove difficulties for businesses. Two main issues were raised: the legal framework for resort real estate, and removing conflicts between laws related to the market.
The National Assembly has now passed the new Law on Investment, amended the Law on Construction and adjusted a number of other articles related to the Law on Construction. So the Law on Investment and the Law on Construction have dealt well with the real estate market bottlenecks raised by the Prime Minister. However, to this day the Land Law remains “idle” after the National Assembly postponed the amendment several times.
Yet this is one of the most important laws, touching the most fields and directly affecting the real estate market. Not only the Land Law itself, this body of law is also tied to some provisions already set out in the Law on Management and Use of Public Property, such as investment projects under BT (build-transfer) contracts, and project bidding.
Recently, the Government issued a Decree on project bidding to select developers, guiding the implementation of the Law on Bidding to replace the old decree, but the Land Law does not provide for bidding for projects that use land. So the question is: in which cases is a project bid with land use, and in which cases is land auctioned?
The second bottleneck in land procedures today is that there is no mechanism to approve projects that include many different types of land, such as public land, ditch banks, canals, public land attached to assets the State is managing, agricultural land, recovered land and so on.
No one knows how to handle projects that include many types of land like this, because there is no rule on what share of land area counts as the main land and what share as secondary land. As a result, no regulator dares to sign off on projects with interspersed public land to be auctioned or bid so that the project can go ahead.
Moreover, auctioning of projects is set out in the law, but bidding is set out in a decree. Choosing between auctioning and bidding a project is a problem with no solution yet. Meanwhile, if a project has not had its site cleared, an auction cannot be held either.
These very bottlenecks have kept projects from being approved. On the other hand, the Government is stepping up its anti-corruption drive, so localities are very cautious in approving projects. This makes projects even more at risk of having their legal procedures “soaked” for longer.
How will so many projects being stuck in the legal framework affect the real estate market?
Prof. Đặng Hùng Võ: All current legal provisions stop at general principles and do not go into the practical implementation of businesses' projects, causing difficulties and “shelving” a large number of real estate projects. Businesses have put a great deal of money into investment, but the projects hang there with no one knowing until when, because there are no specific rules or legal framework to carry them out.
I think this is very dangerous for the real estate market. Recently, very few projects have come onto the market. In the next 2-3 years, the market will face an even more severe supply shortage.
Meanwhile, demand in the market is very large. Vietnam is only 35% urbanized now, and in the next few years this will rise to 50%. Rising urbanization will inevitably increase demand to buy real estate in cities.
The real estate market could fall into a crisis in the future because of insufficient supply. The consequence is that real estate prices rise sharply, price fevers break out in many places and speculators pour into the market. A building real estate bubble threatens the stable and sustainable development of the market.
Projects can't be approved by “climbing over the law”
In fact, the legal procedure bottlenecks in the real estate market that you describe have existed for a long time and are not a story of this period alone, but why is it only in the last few years that these bottlenecks have blocked so many projects?
Prof. Đặng Hùng Võ: It is true that the legal procedure bottlenecks in approving real estate projects have existed in the law for many years. State regulators and businesses both understand this very well.
But in the earlier period, a project approval might not comply with the law, yet as long as the person with authority signed, it was considered done. This was seen as an “OK” way of “applying the law” flexibly, “making allowances” for the project. But now, because the anti-corruption drive has been stepped up, no authority dares to sign off on such projects any more.
The reason is that, in the recent period, very many officials involved in land have been disciplined, some even brought to court and into the grip of the law. Given this reality, those now in office believe it is best not to sign project approvals as before. They see the non-compliance with the law in those projects, and if they put pen to paper, they could be in court immediately.
That is the explanation for why, under the same legal system, projects used to be signed off and approved in large numbers, whereas now they sit idle because of investment procedure bottlenecks.
However, it must be stressed that projects cannot be approved by applying the law carelessly just because we want to bring them to market, or because of legal bottlenecks. The anti-corruption drive, and state regulators being strict in approving projects, are right.
Only this approach can stop corruption, because when projects were signed off as before, some were for good goals for the market, but quite a few were approved because of conflicts of interest.
The issue is how to make state regulators comply with the law in approving projects while also speeding up procedures to create conditions for businesses. To solve this problem, there is no other way than to amend the law to fit market reality and remove the overlaps in land procedures.
Many businesses now say that previously the law allowed them to carry out a project while completing procedures, but now they must complete procedures before carrying out the project, costing businesses a lot of time. In your view, is this new rule reasonable?
Prof. Đặng Hùng Võ: The cause of this situation is the way state regulators apply the law. Previously, a project only needed an investment policy and investment approval to be temporarily allocated land to begin construction. Regulators “made allowances” for businesses to do the project and the procedures at the same time, as long as in the end, when the project was finished, it had full legal status.
Now that can no longer be done, and things must be tightened up according to the law. That is right.
However, the issue is that project approval follows the law, but the current legal system has many shortcomings and so must be amended. Projects cannot be made to sit in one place because of overlapping, impractical legal provisions that lag behind market development.
That is the right way to think; don't think backward. We cannot “climb over the law” and get projects out by any means as regulators did before.
Amending the Land Law is the most important task right now
So in which direction do you think the Land Law should be amended to remove difficulties for projects in the real estate market?
Prof. Đặng Hùng Võ: One of the biggest bottlenecks for real estate projects is interspersed public land. On this issue, I think legal provisions must determine which type of land is the main land so that adjustments follow that type. The main land type here is best calculated by the value of the type of land the project will convert.
The type of land that, after the business changes its use purpose, brings the most benefit to the State should be considered the main land. Other land types are treated according to the main land. If we determine the main land by land area, that would not be suitable, because some land types such as agricultural land have very large areas but very low value.
The second big bottleneck for businesses concerns determining land prices. It can be seen that state regulators are getting carried away with using some mechanism such as bidding or land auctions to overcome the negative practices in land valuation.
But note that these solutions can also have negative practices, such as auction information leaking out, “fixed bidders,” gangs preventing businesses from joining auctions, or colluding with regulators so that a certain business wins.
So auctions and bidding are both solutions in which regulators must follow procedures properly in order to deal with negative practices in land valuation. The most important thing is to value land close to the market before auctioning or bidding.
When land is valued at the market price, the price after an auction may not change from the old price, or if it does change, the price will be higher, which benefits the State more. Bidding is the same.
That is why, in essence, regulators must value land at the market price. After that, whether projects are auctioned or bid does not matter much. Meanwhile, current law does the opposite, fumbling over which mechanism to use while leaving the entire first step of land valuation open.
The mechanism is good if strictly implemented, but it is not a way to completely prevent negative practices.
On approving investment policy: I think that once it is determined that a project is not a special case and does not require bidding, there is no need to go through the investment policy approval procedure. Whatever purpose the land plot is designated for under the plan, the project should be carried out for that purpose.
If done according to that mechanism, there would be no investment policy approval procedure, because investment is already set out in the plan. The requirement to carry out the investment policy procedure exists because in the past there was no specific plan, or plans were made but not carried out, which gave birth to a series of troublesome procedures afterward.
Therefore, planning work must now be redone and plans strictly carried out. If this is achieved, the related procedural steps will naturally be eliminated as unnecessary.
Once again I stress that amending the Land Law is necessary and the most important step to resolve the legal bottlenecks in the real estate market. The State needs to get land to investment projects and bring land into the market. Amending the Land Law would take a month at most, but it has still not been done. If this situation drags on, it will be very dangerous for the real estate market.
Thank you!
Real estate businesses are falling into crisis, but unlike previous oversupply crises, the current crisis concerns the legal status of real estate projects, as investment, construction and land procedures reveal many shortcomings. Hundreds of projects are deadlocked or their implementation is prolonged as businesses spend a great deal of time and money completing legal procedures, which affects new supply and pushes real estate prices up. In light of this situation, TheLEADER begins a special series: “Real estate law: Issues that need to be resolved” to reflect the shortcomings businesses are facing and ways to resolve them while carrying out real estate projects.
According to Thu Phương