There have been cases of investors trimming their profits and selling below their expected profit to stimulate transactions. However, investors who cut prices slightly to sell are not yet the majority at this point.
Prices down slightly by about 7-10% in the secondary market
Observations show that prices of apartments sold by individual investors at this point have leveled off or dropped slightly compared with before Tet. Average prices are recorded at about 7-10% lower than before the pandemic, and at most 15% lower.
For example, according to an investor who owns an apartment on Võ Chí Công Street, District 9, Ho Chi Minh City, before the pandemic a 2-bedroom unit sold for ₫50 million above the purchase price, whereas now the investor will sell to anyone who buys at a premium of about ₫30-40 million.
In another case, at an apartment project on Nguyễn Duy Trinh Street, District 2, Ho Chi Minh City, a 2-bedroom unit was put up for resale with a broker before Tet at ₫2.8 billion per unit, about ₫300 million above the purchase price. But in February 2020 this investor agreed to take ₫2.73 billion, about ₫70 million less profit than previously expected, in order to sell quickly. According to the broker selling this unit, the investor needed money for work and so accepted the lower price to bring in cash, but did not actually want to sell below the expected profit.
The sales manager of a real estate company said that because of the pandemic, workers' incomes have generally fallen, so they are very worried that when handover time comes they will not have the money to take the home. As for investors, in February 2020 secondary apartment transfers were quite lively and prices still rose, because handover was approaching and many genuine buyers were looking at the project. But in March 2020 the pandemic flared up again, the number of customers interested in the project fell, and customers who urgently needed to sell cut their profit by ₫50 million per unit to sell.
So it can be seen that there are cases of investors selling below their expected profit and trimming profits to sell in a market where buyers still want to hold on to their cash, as at present. However, according to brokers, the number of investors who want to sell this kind of product is not large.
A female broker selling apartments in Ho Chi Minh City said that the number of investors listing at prices lower than their original expected price is not common. Only investors who badly need money sell at a small premium or accept breaking even. Most do not accept selling below the purchase price.
Mr. Nguyễn Thái Bình, CEO of Đông Tây Land, said that selling prices have fallen in the secondary apartment market, but not deeply. The maximum cut by selling investors is about 10-15%, but most are around 5-7%. This is a slight decrease. Secondary products with a price cut of around 10% sell quite quickly and find buyers right away, because in practice quite a few investors are always ready and waiting in the low price range to buy.
On why secondary prices have not yet fallen deeply, Mr. Bình said that in the primary market, new selling prices from developers are still quite high with no sign of falling, and some projects have even raised prices along with "stronger" incentive policies than before. For this reason, the secondary market also follows developers' prices as a reference price, which makes deep cuts difficult.
The CEO gave the example of some new apartment projects such as Vinhomes Grand Park (District 9), Dlusso and Citigrand Cát Lái (District 2), where prices launched after the pandemic are still higher than before the pandemic. But transactions are still quite good.
Observations show that, compared with before Lunar New Year, apartment prices in Ho Chi Minh City have neither risen nor fallen. But compared with 1-2 years ago, most apartment projects have risen about 30-50%. While secondary units are dropping slightly at this point, apartment prices in the primary market are not falling and are even still rising. Some projects in District 12 and Bình Chánh and Nhà Bè districts traded at about ₫20-25 million/m² roughly 2 years ago, and developers are now offering new projects at about ₫35-50 million/m² (depending on location and project).
Notably, although prices are high, new supply is scarce, so these projects still see fairly steady transactions even though the market is struggling. According to experts, when developers manage to sell in a period of tight supply, they have also solved their investors' cash flow problem, because most real estate investors do not want their cash to sit still. That is a very easy reality to see.
Investors are still trying to hold on, with no fire sales or loss-cutting yet
The survey shows that most investors still hold their products to wait for a good time to take profits, and there is as yet no wave of fire sales, loss-cutting or selling below purchase price in the apartment market. At most, selling at a loss (below cost) occurs only in a few cases of small investors who use financial leverage on several products at once and cannot keep up financially. However, in recent years real estate lending has been tightened, so the number of investors with this kind of bank "burden" is not large.
Observations show that most investors at present still try to hold on; as they put it, better to leave it than to sell at a loss. That is the general mindset of investors who own apartments in the market.
Mr. Nguyễn Thái Bình said there is currently no fire sale or loss-selling like in 2008. Asked whether, if the difficulties continue, assets would be dumped on the market, Mr. Bình said that this is also very hard to predict and depends on the health of the developers. However, as we have seen over the past few years, with project legal issues in difficulty, the projects that sold were large ones with reputable, well-funded developers. So in my view fire sales are unlikely. In addition, real estate supply in the market is still scarce. Developers with projects know their advantages well, so they will have more solutions to turn to than a fire sale.
Many investors with sound finances say they would rather hold and wait for the right time than sell at a loss. They are still watching the market.
Sharing this view, a representative of a real estate company headquartered in District 7, Ho Chi Minh City, said that overall there will be no dumping of products in the market. In fact, new products launched at this time even have "sky-high prices." Compared with selling at a loss, most investors choose to keep their holdings and wait, which remains the more promising option. In reality, these investors' money is not only in 1-2 apartments but may be in other investments as well. They will watch, and if the market is unstable they will temporarily move to other investment channels. Then when the market stabilizes they will still come back to real estate. In the mindset of long-time real estate investors, profits from real estate are still faster and larger than from other investments.
One real estate broker shared that a customer who invests in many places also mortgaged assets to borrow from banks. This investor left a unit with the broker to sell. When the broker asked, "If the bank is pressing you too hard, let me list it at a loss to sell quickly," the investor said, "No need, sell it if you can, otherwise just leave it." In another case, at an apartment project that is not yet finished, some investors also used bank financing to invest, but according to this broker, when customers were asked about taking their units for resale because the project's secondary market is quite stable, most of those asked did not want to sell at this time.
This shows that the pandemic has slowed the overall market, but real estate investors still expect higher profits because they judge that the market has not reached the point of cutting losses, not to mention that these investors already have financial resources in reserve. In most affordable projects, they target genuine housing demand, and after the pandemic they will be able to sell, with good expected profits.
According to inquiries, at an apartment project near Tân Sơn Nhất Airport, although it is still affected by legal issues and no certificates have yet been issued to residents, it is very hard right now to find an apartment for sale there in the secondary market. Investors prefer to live in their units or rent them out rather than sell in a hurry, because they know that genuine housing demand in this area is still very large.
Source: Nhịp sống kinh tế