Businesses are exhausted by having to pass through “a hundred doors and a hundred stamps” to complete the legal procedures for a real estate project.
Real estate projects with “no way out”
“Real estate businesses are being pushed into a position of sitting on hot coals in the face of a maze of legal procedures,” the head of a Hanoi company said of the difficulties real estate businesses commonly face today.
According to this developer: “When carrying out a project, businesses grit their teeth to get the work done so the project can reach the market. But when everything is finished and you look back, all you feel is ‘fear.’ If I were forced to go through the procedures for that project again, I am sure I would not have the courage to get through them.”
“Before, there were hard channels and ‘soft’ channels. Now both hard and soft are difficult. Every door seems shut tight against businesses,” he added.
For the past two years, getting projects approved has been very difficult. His company currently has a project in Da Nang that is in the process of applying for a construction permit. Almost every month he has to fly back and forth several times to “chase” the investment procedures, but he does not know when all the legal requirements can be completed as required.
Among those caught between tears and laughter, the unfinished story of Đỗ Anh Dũng, Chairman of Tân Hoàng Minh Group, in completing the legal procedures for a project at the Hàng Bài – Hai Bà Trưng intersection in Hoàn Kiếm District, Hanoi, deserves mention.
According to Mr. Dũng, he bought this nearly 4,000 m² plot in 2007, and it took four years to finish clearing the site. He then spent another four years to obtain the land allocation decision, and to this day the project has still not had its land use fee calculated. One plot of land has gone 14 to 15 years without the procedures being completed.
“For a real estate project to complete its legal procedures, it has to seek approval through ‘a hundred doors and a hundred stamps,’ which exhausts businesses,” Mr. Dũng said.
This is also a common and knotty problem for businesses in the real estate market today. Many projects are stuck in procedures and “frozen” because of legal obstacles.
In fact, since late 2018, vigorous inspections and reviews of projects with violations, together with bottlenecks in approving investment policies for new projects, have made it difficult to obtain permits for projects.
According to statistics from the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA), in 2018 Ho Chi Minh City had only 19 projects recognized with a developer, 59 projects granted investment approval and 53 projects granted construction permits, with a total of 39,959 apartments and a total area of 3,263,212 m². That was a 42% drop in the number of projects, a 40% drop in the number of apartments and a 74% drop in the total area of housing projects compared with 2017.
In the first nine months of 2019, the number of projects with completed legal status fell to an even more “dismal” level: the whole city had only one housing project approved for an investment policy, down about 83%; no housing project recognized with a developer; only 12 projects granted investment approval, down about 72%; and only 24 projects granted construction permits, down about 38%, compared with the same period of 2018.
One of the biggest legal obstacles for real estate projects is that they are caught with interspersed public land. According to HoREA statistics, 158 projects in the city currently have public land problems with no way out. Of these, 124 projects have been allowed by the city to resume operations but still cannot proceed normally.
One of the businesses that has felt this “pain” is a “giant” of the Ho Chi Minh City real estate market, Novaland. To date, some of its projects still cannot obtain ownership certificates for residents because of interspersed public land, even where the parcels are only a few hundred square meters.
A typical example is the Khải Vy mixed residential and commercial project in Phú Thuận Ward, District 7. The site covers about 77,354.8 m², of which 1,758.5 m² is public land scattered across the project, including canal land and land recovered to build local roads. Just because of public land within the project, the company has not been issued a red book (land use rights certificate) and has not been allocated land to carry out the project.
It is not only Novaland. Many other businesses have fallen into similar difficulty. One example is the Green Star Sky Garden project of Hưng Lộc Phát Company in District 7, Ho Chi Minh City. The project is on 52,648 m² of land, with two types of housing developed: an adjoining townhouse area and high-rise apartments. For the townhouse area, the project falls under a case exempt from a construction permit.
However, in mid-2019, the project was suspended from construction for 60 days on the grounds of building 110 villas without permission, because the Ho Chi Minh City People's Committee had not issued a land allocation decision and the change of land use purpose had not been completed.
Notably, the reason the developer cannot carry out the legal procedures is that the project currently has more than 7,000 m² of public land (14% of its area) tied up in canals and roads managed by the State.
Besides problems from public land within projects, the matter of land valuation has also caused businesses considerable difficulty recently. Except for small-scale real estate projects with a land use fee below ₫30 billion, which use the “land price table method” to calculate a project's land use fee, all remaining projects must apply the land price determination methods under Decree 44/2014/ND-CP to determine a “specific land price” in line with the market, in order to calculate the project's land use fee.
For nearly two years, many commercial housing projects have not had their land use fees calculated, so developers face serious financial difficulty, with higher interest costs and management costs that raise production costs and lose business opportunities.
As a result, the process and procedures for determining and appraising land prices are prolonged, often around two years or longer. One cause is the canal land, embankments and State-managed roads interspersed within projects, as described above, which delay issuing decisions to recover and allocate land.
Businesses left to “swim” alone in a maze of procedures
Besides overlapping legal regulations, the legal deadlock also shows in the fact that there is no specific process for businesses to complete investment procedures for a real estate project.
In the past, developers built while completing procedures, but now businesses must complete many procedures relating to investment, land and finance all at once before being permitted to build the project.
Mr. Trịnh Văn Quyết, Chairman of FLC Group, said that for the FLC Sầm Sơn project, which broke ground in 2015, the company took only 11 months to complete the legal paperwork while building each stage, from pile driving to the main structure.
However, “the current mechanism does not allow businesses to build while applying for permits. So businesses must spend at least three years completing all legal procedures before they can start construction. The project timeline is therefore prolonged, causing great difficulty for businesses.”
“Legal status plays a very important role for a real estate project. But over the past two years, carrying out legal procedures has become harder and harder. Almost every problem with a project involves legal issues. Businesses are afraid at the very thought of legal matters,” Mr. Quyết said with concern.
Another difficulty for real estate businesses today is that there is still no specific process or procedure for approving projects. Recently, the Ho Chi Minh City Department of Construction proposed shortening the project approval procedures and sequence from six steps to five. But so far this process has not been agreed on because of many opposing views.
The five project approval steps proposed by Ho Chi Minh City are: Step 1 is preparing the procedure for deciding on the investment policy. Step 2 is preparing the 1/500 detailed zoning plan. Step 3 is preparing the procedure for land allocation or leasing and for changing the land use purpose.
Step 4 is carrying out the procedure to determine financial obligations and pay the land use fee. Step 5 is preparing the procedure to issue the residential land use rights certificate, recognize the developer, approve the investment, issue the construction permit and carry out construction investment.
Under this process, many businesses have “cried out,” because if followed correctly it could take 5 to 10 years to finish the procedures for one project. Mr. Lê Hoàng Châu, Chairman of HoREA, pointed out that the cause is that the process for determining land prices, appraising land prices and determining the land use fee takes a great deal of time. Businesses must wait a very long time before they can pay the land use fee, which delays the housing project. This procedure takes about two years, but many projects take three years or more.
Therefore, the rule that businesses must pay the land use fee before being recognized as the developer, before the project design is appraised, before the construction permit is issued and before construction can start is not consistent with current legal regulations.
“If the land use fee must be paid at Step 4, businesses will have their capital tied up for about 5 to 7 years or longer. This rule needs to be reconsidered,” Mr. Châu recommended.
Because of these unresolved debates, there is still no agreed project approval process for real estate businesses to this day. The legal obstacles in the real estate market persist, leaving a string of projects stalled and deadlocked. The inevitable result is a sharp fall in real estate supply, which in turn pushes home prices up.
Besides prices rising because of insufficient supply, another cause, according to Mr. Nguyễn Văn Đính, Vice Chairman of the Vietnam Association of Realtors, is the obstacles in legal procedures.
Mr. Đính said that state management agencies always talk about how to get affordable, low-priced housing to meet people's needs, yet they allow investment procedures to drag on.
Some projects that should take only one year take five, and some even take 15 years. This is extremely dangerous because a project that began as affordable housing may, once finished, force the business to raise the selling price to cover additional costs from keeping a staff on payroll, capital costs and other investment costs caused by the prolonged timeline. In the end, the project is sold at a much higher price.
“In Ho Chi Minh City, many projects that should be priced at ₫18–20 million/m² have been pushed to sell for more than ₫30 million/m². Meanwhile, the quality has not changed. It is simply that the businesses have gone over budget and so have to set high prices,” Mr. Đính observed.
According to Mr. Đính, to help create conditions for businesses and the real estate market to develop, state management agencies need to step in decisively to resolve the obstacles in project legal procedures.
“Legal policies must be tied to reality and reach reality faster, and cannot keep trailing behind the market as they do now,” Mr. Đính proposed.
According to TheLEADER