Difficulty accessing capital, a 10% profit cap and continued legal risk are barriers that make businesses reluctant to build social housing.
The HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA) has just submitted to the Government the unreasonable points and remaining obstacles in implementing social housing policy. The association also proposes quick changes to promote the development of the low-priced housing market and help people settle down.
Blocked capital
HoREA notes that neither developers of social housing projects nor buyers of this product line have had access to preferential credit. Blocked capital has been the biggest bottleneck for many years, because of the delay in allocating state budget funds (as seed capital) to carry out social housing policy.
The association explains that seed capital from the State budget plays a very important role in promoting social housing development. For example, with the ₫30,000 billion preferential credit package, for every ₫1 of state budget used to subsidize interest, commercial banks can mobilize an additional ₫33 from social capital (33 times as much). In practice, banks do lend to social housing projects now, but developers and buyers both have to borrow at commercial interest rates of 9% to 10% a year. This makes it even harder for social housing buyers, whose budgets are already tight, to repay their loans and interest.
The latest development that could ease this bottleneck, according to HoREA, came in April 2020, when the Government allocated ₫3,000 billion from the state budget, of which ₫1,000 billion went to refinancing the Vietnam Bank for Social Policies and ₫2,000 billion to interest rate subsidies, allocated to 4 banks: Vietcombank, Vietinbank, BIDV and Agribank. With this refinancing, the 4 commercial banks can mobilize up to about ₫60,000 billion to support preferential credit for social housing buyers in 2020 and the next few years.
Inconsistent interest rates on social housing loans
In 2019, the Government issued a Decision on the interest rate range for loans to buy social housing at the Vietnam Bank for Social Policies. Under it, the loan interest rate must be no lower than the rate for loans supporting poor households with housing, and must not exceed the preferential lending rate of the credit institutions designated by the State for buying, renting or lease-purchasing social housing under Decree 100.
In practice, however, there is no consistency in this preferential rate. Social housing buyers at the Vietnam Bank for Social Policies get preferential loans at 4.8% a year. Social housing buyers at the 4 commercial banks get preferential loans at 5% a year.
HoREA's view is that social housing buyers all have very low incomes and need support. A difference in preferential rates among credit institutions should therefore not apply to them. This inconsistency in preferential loan policy needs to be fixed in the coming period to ensure fairness and equality for those seeking low-priced housing.
Rental social housing taxed higher than the law provides
The Housing Law provides that building social housing for rent qualifies for larger cuts in value-added tax and corporate income tax than building social housing for lease-purchase or sale. Decree 100 also states that investment in building social housing solely for rent receives a 70% reduction in the VAT and corporate income tax rates under current tax regulations for social housing.
In practice, however, the General Department of Taxation has instructed that businesses building rental housing receive only a 5% VAT incentive and are subject to a 10% corporate income tax rate. HoREA argues that this application of tax policy does not encourage private businesses to invest in developing rental social housing projects.
The profit cap on social housing investment is a step backward
Decree 100 sets the standard profit of the whole project at no more than 10% of total investment cost, but HoREA believes this cap is unreasonable. That profit level does not encourage businesses to invest in social housing projects. This is because many unnamed costs, including the actual cost of site clearance, are not counted properly and fully in total investment cost, so developers lose out and may even lose money.
In addition, the profit cap does not encourage project developers to apply advances in technology, engineering and management to both ensure construction quality and add amenities and services while saving costs and reducing prices. On that basis, developers would earn additional profit. According to HoREA, the State should instead only control planning, construction quality and above all the selling price of social housing, to encourage businesses to innovate, be creative and work efficiently.
Major legal risk
Although the State encourages social housing and offers more incentive policies, in practice these projects with mixed land funds are held up by investment and construction procedures similar to those for commercial housing projects. The biggest legal bottleneck at present is that there are no regulations on bidding criteria for selecting developers to use public land managed by the State, which leads to wasted land funds.
The lack of investment and construction procedures for social housing projects by businesses that obtained land through land use rights transfers is also a common blockage. Moreover, social housing projects have no streamlined investment and construction procedures, so completing the legal paperwork takes a long time, causing cost overruns, higher costs and difficulty keeping prices affordable.
HoREA adds that signs of profiteering in implementing social housing policy have appeared in the real estate market, such as selling homes to ineligible buyers and transferring homes in violation of the law. The association recommends that, alongside social housing, a mechanism is also needed to develop low-priced commercial housing to encourage expansion of the affordable housing market. This would attract businesses to participate and give low-income people the chance to settle down.
By Trung Tín (VnExpress)