Land disputes are the most complex issue among civil cases and often arise in daily life. This type of dispute can be resolved by filing a lawsuit in court or by lodging a complaint with the competent State agency, each with a different process and procedure.
What is a land dispute?
Under the 2013 Land Law, a land dispute is a dispute over the rights and obligations of land users between two or more parties in a land relationship. Basically, land disputes fall into three types:
– Disputes over land use rights: disputes between parties over who has the lawful right to use a particular plot of land.
In this type of dispute, we often see disputes over land boundaries; disputes over land use rights and assets attached to land in divorce and inheritance matters; disputes to reclaim land; and so on.
– Disputes over rights and obligations arising in the course of land use: this type of dispute often occurs when parties have civil transactions over land use rights, such as disputes over rights and obligations in transfer or lease contracts for land use rights, or disputes related to compensation for site clearance, support and resettlement when the State reclaims land.
– Disputes over land use purpose. This type is less common; these disputes concern determining what the land use purpose is.
Usually these disputes also have an easy basis for resolution, because when allocating land to users, the State has already determined the land use purpose through land-use planning. The disputes mainly arise when land users use the land for a purpose different from the one for which the State allocated or leased it.
Process for resolving land disputes
Lawyer Phạm Thị Bích Hảo, Director of Đức An Law Co., Ltd., said that under the regulations, land disputes in which the parties hold a land use rights certificate or one of the types of papers specified in Article 100 of the law, and disputes over assets attached to land, are resolved by the People's Court.
“Land disputes are often difficult and complex. Mediation is the first step, and the State encourages the parties to reconcile among themselves. The State encourages parties to a land dispute to mediate themselves or to resolve the dispute through grassroots mediation. If the parties to a land dispute cannot reach reconciliation, they send an application to the commune-level People's Committee where the disputed land is located for mediation,” lawyer Hảo added.
Step 1: Grassroots mediation
The Chairman of the commune-level People's Committee is responsible for organizing mediation of land disputes in the locality and coordinating with the commune-level Vietnam Fatherland Front Committee, its member organizations and other social organizations to carry out the mediation.
The mediation procedure must be completed within no more than 45 days from the date of receiving the application requesting resolution of the land dispute.
The mediation must be recorded in minutes signed by the parties, with confirmation from the commune-level People's Committee that the mediation succeeded or failed. The mediation minutes are sent to the disputing parties and kept at the commune-level People's Committee where the disputed land is located.
After unsuccessful mediation, for a land dispute involving a land use rights certificate, you can send an application to the People's Court requesting resolution.
Step 2: Procedure for resolving land disputes in court
The plaintiff sends the complaint with documents and evidence to the competent court. The court then receives it and issues a notice on advance payment of court fees to complete the file. In some cases the court asks the plaintiff to make corrections, and in some cases the court returns the file if it does not yet meet the conditions.
When the parties have a complete file, have received the notice and paid the advance court fee, the court accepts the case and conducts mediation between the parties so they can agree on how to settle the case. Mediation is always prioritized, even after a lawsuit has been filed. It is a mandatory procedure in the resolution of civil cases, led and conducted by the court.
If, within 7 days, the parties agree to the settlement, the court records successful mediation and the dispute ends.
If the parties cannot reconcile, the court continues with the procedures to bring the case to trial.
The time limit for resolving a dispute under the law is 4 months, extendable by 2 months. In practice, however, some cases drag on for several years, even 10 years, because the procedures, and the formal and substantive aspects of resolving land disputes, are quite complex.
Where there is no red book, or the dispute does not involve assets attached to land, such as disputes over access paths, boundaries or boundary markers, you can submit an application for dispute resolution to the People's Committee of the competent level.
For disputes between households, individuals and communities, the complaint goes to the competent authority, the Chairman of the district-level People's Committee. If one of the parties does not agree the first time, they can complain to the provincial level, or even file an administrative lawsuit against the district-level People's Committee's resolution decision itself.
Source: Cafeland