Transactions to buy or sell property without a red book (land use rights certificate) are not considered legal, so they always carry risks that not everyone knows in advance. Many people accept buying land without a red book hoping that after buying they can legalize it and gain a larger value, while others, unfamiliar with the law, end up buying this kind of land by mistake.
Land without a red book usually falls into two cases. The first is land that does not meet the conditions for a red book, so land use rights may not be transferred because the conditions are not met; the second is land that meets the conditions but has not yet been issued a red book or the holder has not yet applied for one.
By regulation, if land meets the conditions for a red book but has not been issued one, and the land user wants to transfer it, they must obtain the red book before transferring the land use rights to someone else.
Obtaining the red book before drawing up the land use rights transfer agreement is a mandatory procedure, because without a red book the transaction cannot be notarized and the red book title cannot be transferred.
Risks of buying and selling property without a red book
According to experts, except for a few cases that can be legalized and granted a red book, most buyers will bear legal consequences.
According to experts, except for a few cases that can be legalized and granted a red book, most buyers will bear legal consequences.
First, after receiving a transfer of this kind of land, the transferee cannot obtain a red book because the land does not meet the conditions for one.
Second, the land use purpose cannot be changed from agricultural land, non-agricultural land or other land to residential land because it does not conform to zoning. If agricultural land is traded to be used for agricultural production, the effect is not great, but for agricultural land bought to be converted to residential land, you need to pay particular attention to this issue.
Third, because the land has no red book, the sale can only be done with a handwritten agreement, which gives no legal assurance and is prone to disputes that make the sale agreement void. Without a red book it is very hard to verify the origin of the land, and there are many hidden risks such as encroached land, land in dispute, agricultural land and even land already subject to a reclamation decision… As a result, the buyer may face legal disputes at any time.
Under Article 188 of the 2013 Land Law, land use rights may be mortgaged only if the land has a red book. So if you need a bank loan, you cannot mortgage the land without a red book.
Fourth, although state agencies rarely act on this, under Decree 102/2014/ND-CP, arbitrarily transferring land use rights when the conditions are not met is subject to penalty. A fine of ₫3–5 million applies to arbitrarily transferring, gifting, leasing, subleasing, mortgaging or contributing capital with land use rights when there is no land use rights certificate, the land is in dispute, the land is under seizure to secure judgment enforcement, or the land use term has expired and was not extended by the competent state agency. The violator is also required to hand over the illegal gains obtained from the violation.
What to do when you buy land without a red book?
If you have already bought land without a red book, experts say it is best to make a deposit agreement. The agreement must clearly state the seller's commitments and compensation for failing to fulfill them. In addition, you should also have a power of attorney for managing, using and disposing of the land, so that when the plot meets the conditions for a certificate you can proactively carry out the procedures yourself.
If you have already bought land without a red book, experts say it is best to make a deposit agreement. The agreement must clearly state the seller's commitments and compensation for failing to fulfill them. In addition, you should also have a power of attorney for managing, using and disposing of the land, so that when the plot meets the conditions for a certificate you can proactively carry out the procedures yourself.
To limit possible risks, you need to look into the land's origin: is it legal residential land, is it encroached land? Is the land in a zoning area? When a house is built, would the competent authority order its forced demolition? Is the property currently in dispute with other parties?
You can verify this information through the construction and land officers of the People's Committee of the commune or ward where the land is. If the plot has any of these problems, buying and selling it carries very high risk.
You also need to check the seller's identity documents. If the seller is married, the sale agreement must involve both spouses. Ask the seller to hand over the originals of the papers on the property's origin (if any).
The transfer document should be witnessed by two neighbors, and you can ask the seller to put a right index fingerprint on the agreement. Payment should be made at a bank, or you should ask the seller to write a receipt for the money.
Sale agreement for property without a red book
Buying property without a red book carries many risks because the legal procedures cannot be carried out. The buyer should firmly insist on the seller's pledge to apply for the red book after signing the sale agreement, because every property transaction must be notarized to be valid under the law.
Buying property without a red book carries many risks because the legal procedures cannot be carried out. The buyer should firmly insist on the seller's pledge to apply for the red book after signing the sale agreement, because every property transaction must be notarized to be valid under the law.
There is also no standard template guiding the process and procedures for buying and selling property. Below are only the main contents of a handwritten sale agreement for property without a red book:
- Information on both parties: the transferor and the transferee.
- Rights to use the land plot being transferred and the assets attached to the land, including specific details of the plot such as plot number, map sheet number, plot address and land area…
- Transfer price and payment method.
- Terms on handing over the land and registering land use rights.
- Responsibility for paying taxes and other fees.
- How disputes will be resolved if they arise.
- Pledges on the parties' responsibilities.
Among these, the buyer must pay attention to some content that binds the seller to obtain the red book after the transfer:
- The seller is responsible for applying to the competent authorities for a red book for the plot and land area as agreed to be sold to the buyer.
- Both parties agree to draw up a sale agreement for property without a red book in order to transfer the land use rights.
- After signing this agreement, the seller carries out the procedures to apply for the red book, to notarize the land use rights transfer agreement, and to transfer the red book title, in accordance with the law.
Property without a red book may not be bought or sold. So if the property meets the conditions, the owner must obtain the red book before drawing up the sale agreement.
Thus, faced with the legal risks, land buyers should think carefully about buying land that has no red book, or buying through a handwritten agreement. Investing in this kind of land requires knowledge of land law, a firm grasp of information about the plot, and readiness to accept possible risks.
According to Cafefland