Citics draws attention not only for its multimillion-dollar funding news but also because the startup brings together big names in the startup world, such as Trần Minh Long, who laid the foundation for CEN Group in southern Vietnam, Nguyễn Hải Ninh, founder of The Coffee House, and Phạm Anh Đức, founder of ViCare… Citics' CEO said he expects the startup to reach break-even by the end of this year or early 2022.
“From graduating until starting my own company, I worked for only one company, CEN Group,” said Trần Minh Long, founder and CEO of Citics.
Nearly 9 years is a journey long enough to give your all, and long enough to renew yourself, step out of your comfort zone and pursue your own dream.
Long gave up his position as Executive Director of CEN Group in the South and founded Citics Joint Stock Company in late 2018. His motivation for starting up at the time, Long said, was the wish to contribute his effort to solving the pain points of the real estate market by applying the power of technology, something a traditional model cannot do.
“The biggest problem of the real estate market today is that information is not transparent, and is scattered and fragmented. This makes transactions around property, such as buying, selling, valuing, renting and lending, complicated, time-consuming and inefficient.”
“This is a hard problem. I think the issues I worry about may not necessarily be solved, but if we don't start working on them, they will never be solved,” Long said.
By applying the power of technology and digitizing many fragmented data sources, Citics aims to build a comprehensive real estate data platform so that transactions around property (buying, selling, valuing, renting, lending, investing and so on) can take place seamlessly, conveniently and efficiently.
Signed with 10 banks; if all goes well, break-even by the end of 2021
* Why did Long choose the valuation field when he left CEN Group to start his own company?
First, Citics is a real estate data company, and valuation is Citics' first product for banks in Vietnam, used to verify the value of a property serving as collateral for loans.
We are researching the next products, but Long believes that once there is a data system that is large enough, we can do a lot more.
* Specifically, which “pain points” of the market does Citics hope to solve?
Valuation has been formed and developed in Vietnam for nearly 20 years. But we almost only hear about this profession when we need to value an asset for bank mortgage loans or for a few other purposes such as buying and selling assets.
The value of a property is usually very large, so the decisions that follow have significant consequences. Long believes that accurate and transparent valuation is also something necessary and decent in Vietnam.
* Why do banks want to work with Citics rather than a traditional property valuation firm?
When working with banks, there are 2 things that bank head offices care about most when outsourcing to a valuation company:
– Risk control: The valuation must reflect the true market value, and the information in the report must be transparent. The traditional way depends entirely on people and on the subjectivity of a few individuals, without a system that can control the information. In many cases there can also be collusion and misconduct aimed at valuing a property above its real value to borrow more, or the reverse. When the valuation is off, the bank bears the risk.
– Time: Fast and convenient. At present the traditional way takes 2–3 days or longer to deliver a result. This slows down the process of providing loans to customers.
Citics solves this problem. In addition, it provides many specialized working tools for banks, helps bank head offices manage centrally, and costs much less than the market. Citics is the first company to pioneer applying technology and data to the industry to change the entire way the valuation industry operates.
Until now, when working with a traditional valuation company, banks required the partner to have 5 years of experience before they would consider other scores. With its database and operating model, Citics, less than 2 years old, has completely changed this view and now serves 10 banks.
* Who are Citics' customers? Who is willing to pay Citics?
70% of collateral at banks today is real estate. Before lending to a customer, a mandatory step is to verify how much that asset is worth. Citics' customers can be banks or borrowers. The one who uses the valuation result is the one who pays.
* According to the plan, when will Citics reach break-even?
With this round of capital, Citics is focusing on 2 things: the valuation product and data. If conditions are favorable, we will reach break-even at the end of this year or early next year. But we certainly want to go further than that.
3 factors that convinced investors to put in millions of dollars
* Citics recently raised US$1 million. That is a very impressive figure given the resurgence of COVID-19 and the fact that real estate is not considered an essential sector. How did the team approach and convince investors?
Citics began fundraising in August 2020, when COVID was ongoing. Not only real estate but all non-essential industries were affected. On the subject of fundraising, in Vietnam there are relatively few funds or investors active, and most startups so far have raised money from foreign investors. When COVID struck, most foreign investors could not come to Vietnam, and it was almost impossible to get to know a company or do DD (due diligence before investing).
I am glad that in the latest round, our existing investors fully trusted the company's development and its team and continued to invest, in addition to the investment from new investors.
To convince investors, I think 3 factors are needed:
– Vision: You must have a vision big enough, a dream big enough.
– Product–market fit: We already had a first product, valuation, that fits the market. During COVID, we still grew revenue by about 20–30% every month.
– Team: A team that is cohesive, passionate and knows the industry very well.
For any startup, these are the 3 factors investors care about. We also used these 3 factors to convince investors. Each investor has a different investment appetite. Our view is to find investors who share our vision and are the right fit.
I am glad that in the latest round, our existing investors fully trusted the company's development and its team and continued to invest, in addition to the investment from new investors.
To convince investors, I think 3 factors are needed:
– Vision: You must have a vision big enough, a dream big enough.
– Product–market fit: We already had a first product, valuation, that fits the market. During COVID, we still grew revenue by about 20–30% every month.
– Team: A team that is cohesive, passionate and knows the industry very well.
For any startup, these are the 3 factors investors care about. We also used these 3 factors to convince investors. Each investor has a different investment appetite. Our view is to find investors who share our vision and are the right fit.
* Citics was founded in late 2018, and the news of raising US$1 million was only announced recently. Before successfully raising US$1 million, how did Citics “live”?
In fact, we lived with no revenue at all for more than a year. At that time our goal was not how many orders we sold or how much revenue we made each month, but how to structure things to build the largest and most accurate data warehouse.
10 million data points was our first goal then. I believe that correct and sufficient data will be a golden key to open the door to a breakthrough for many services around real estate.
Luckily, we had a steadfast team that shared one belief. At first the startup lived on my money and that of a few companions. When the money was nearly gone, with enthusiasm and vision we raised almost another US$1 million from domestic angel investors. Then, once our first product, valuation, was launched, we grew from there and began to have revenue.
10 million data points was our first goal then. I believe that correct and sufficient data will be a golden key to open the door to a breakthrough for many services around real estate.
Luckily, we had a steadfast team that shared one belief. At first the startup lived on my money and that of a few companions. When the money was nearly gone, with enthusiasm and vision we raised almost another US$1 million from domestic angel investors. Then, once our first product, valuation, was launched, we grew from there and began to have revenue.
“Before Ninh and Đức joined, I also hesitated about whether friends working together would be afraid of disagreements”
* Citics' leadership team is also impressive. Nguyễn Hải Ninh, founder of The Coffee House, and Phạm Anh Đức, founder of ViCare, are both from the Forbes Under 30 list. How did you find your partners?
I was very lucky to be selected for the Forbes Under 30 list and to meet friends like Ninh and Đức. After that, we spent time together and gradually became close. Outside Citics, they are also close friends of mine.
When I started Citics, I worked for almost a year before sharing my path and dream. I was very lucky to have my friends' support and company. Ninh and Đức were also our first two angel investors.
* People often say you should not do business with friends…
I think each person is like a puzzle piece, with different strengths. Before Ninh and Đức joined Citics, I also hesitated a lot about the idea of “us friends” hanging out together and working together. In many cases, working together can lead to disagreements and people stop being friends.
But they themselves were also founders before, having sat in the seat I am in now, and we came together with the mindset of working together and solving the market's challenges together. Starting a business is like taking on a challenging journey, and I am really glad to have friends like these sharing that journey with me.
* Citics' team also includes a prominent name, Mr. Jani Rautiainen, co-founder and chief executive of the well-known real estate startup PropertyGuru, which bought 100% of the website batdongsan.com.vn in 2018. What brought Citics to invite Jani as an adviser?
Wanting to learn more from those who came before us, through a friend's introduction we had the chance to meet Jani, a real veteran of real estate startups. Before Citics, Jani had also met many other proptech companies in Vietnam. Perhaps it was Citics' different way of working, together with its vision and aspiration, that convinced Jani to join as an adviser to the Board of Directors. Not only that, Vulpes Venture, where Jani is a partner, is also one of the investors in this round.
* Looking at the real estate market during COVID-19, where do you see the opportunities and challenges for proptech companies like Citics?
One opportunity for proptech companies in particular, and technology-driven businesses in general, is that when COVID happened, digital transformation moved faster.
As for challenges, as everyone has seen, COVID affected not only the real estate market but all non-essential industries, and the first impact was on revenue. Meanwhile, for a startup, cash flow is very important.
Fundraising is also difficult for startups, when foreign investors cannot come to Vietnam to learn about a company or do DD. That is why companies must know how to be flexible so they manage costs as well as possible and invest in essential activities. Either create a better product, or create revenue growth, or else drop it. Cash flow planning used to cover maybe 12 months, but now you have to be ready to plan for longer, 16 months, even 18–24 months.
* Thank you for sharing!
Source: https://cafebiz.vn/startup-cua-3-nguoi-ban-than-tu-forbes-under-30-nhung-nguoi-tung-khoi-nghiep-se-biet-cach-ho-tro-nhau-cung-giai-thach-thuc-cua-thi-truong-bds-20210319084153814.chn
Text and photos: Citics Culture and Communications Team