With new land price tables for 2020-2024 raising prices many times over in many places, many experts worry that owning a home will become even more out of reach for ordinary people, especially those on low incomes.
A land price table is a set of land prices for each type of land, issued by the provincial People's Committee on the basis of the land valuation method and the land price brackets.
Land price tables expected to jump sharply
Under the Land Law 2013, the Government issues land price brackets every 5 years and publishes them on January 1 of the first year of the period. Accordingly, local land price tables for the current period (2014-2019) expire on December 31, 2019. Many localities across the country have therefore begun to build new land price tables for 2020-2024.
In Nghệ An Province, the Resolution on the land price table for 2020-2024 was passed at the 12th session (December 12, 2019) of the provincial People's Council. Accordingly, from January 1, 2020, prices of all types of land in Nghệ An will rise considerably from the 2014-2019 land price table. For example, the highest residential land price in Vinh City is ₫65 million/m² (up 27.5%). In the districts, the highest price is ₫15 million/m² (up as much as 87.5%).
In Bình Dương, the new land price table is expected to rise by 45% to 95% from the current one. Accordingly, the Thủ Dầu Một City area will rise by an average of 50% from the current table, Thuận An and Dĩ An towns by an average of 95%, Bến Cát and Tân Uyên towns by an average of 60%, and Bàu Bàng and Bắc Tân Uyên districts by an average of 80%.
In Hanoi, the city People's Committee agreed to propose only an average 15% increase in land prices for 2020-2024 over 2014-2019, instead of the 30% originally calculated. Accordingly, the residential land price table rises by an average of 16% for two-way main roads and by an average of 12% for one-way roads.
HCMC is also building a new land price table, expected to be adjusted up by 30% to 50%.
According to the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, after the Government issues the land price brackets, the adjustment in land prices for each area compared with the previous brackets will be published in detail so that provincial and city People's Committees can use it as a basis for building and adjusting local land price tables.
The ministry also explained that the brackets are only a basis for building price tables, and exactly what percentage increase to apply above the prescribed brackets is for each locality to decide.
Anxious about rising home prices
Raising land price brackets helps people whose land is recovered lose less, speeds up compensation and site clearance, and makes land-based budget revenue more effective.
However, higher land price brackets also worry many people that the input costs of real estate products will rise, pushing up home prices and putting their dream of buying a home further out of reach.
Looking at this issue, Mr. Nguyễn Quốc Hiệp, Chairman of GP Invest, said: “In residential real estate projects, land costs usually account for 10% to 14% of the cost. When land prices rise by half, this figure will reach 25%, so selling prices will certainly have to rise. Not only that, higher land costs will also push up the prices of everything related to construction, such as cement, steel and bricks. That will drive up the cost of housing. At that point, I don't know whether consumers will accept it.”
Sharing this view, Mr. Lê Hoàng Châu, Chairman of the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA), said that land use fees make up roughly 10% of the cost of an apartment, roughly 30% of the cost of a townhouse and roughly 50% of the cost of a villa. The cost is the basis on which developers decide the selling price of housing products on the market. Therefore, higher land price brackets and tables will inevitably have a direct effect on raising home and land prices, making it harder for middle-income and low-income urban residents to acquire housing.
“Today an affordable 2-bedroom commercial apartment costs roughly ₫2 billion. For a couple (with 1 child) earning about ₫20 million a month who save very frugally, they can only put aside about ₫5 to 6 million a month (₫60 to 70 million a year), so the dream of acquiring a home is even further away unless they get preferential social housing credit,” Mr. Châu explained.
In contrast to these worries, some experts predict that when land prices rise, the cost of real estate products will not be affected very much.
Ms. Trần Thị Khánh Linh, Head of Valuation at Savills Vietnam in HCMC, explained: “Under the Land Law 2013, real estate projects worth more than ₫30 billion do not rely on the land price table but must use market valuation to determine financial obligations. So adjusting the State's land price brackets does not greatly affect the input costs of real estate projects, and so the cost of real estate products is not greatly affected either.”
Ms. Linh also said that a 5-year period for the land price table is quite long because real estate prices change quickly. So there could be small adjustment periods, such as 6 months or 1 year, to reflect market movements.
At the same time, provincial and city People's Committees should be given more authority to act on their own when issuing land price tables, to ensure the principle that land prices match prevailing market land prices and the actual situation of each locality.