Why single-family rental projects are taking the lead in the real estate market.
Turn on any news broadcast these days and the phrase you hear quite often is the ‘new normal.’ An expectation has been set that the COVID-19 crisis has permanently changed everything we know and that we need to accept that unforeseeable event.
I have a slightly different view, especially as everything changes in the single-family rental business.
The world is always in a cycle of change. That was even more true before COVID-19, and it will keep changing without end after we find a vaccine. This has been normal since I got into the single-family rental business 15 years ago and grew with it over time. For example, building an entire tract of homes for rent did not exist 15 years ago. Yet today, it is an emerging trend.
Here is another, more visible proof of the pandemic's impact. Instead of being lazy, watch how things are changing in the new normal:
Some existing trends are accelerating. For example, online conferencing and working from home were trends that had already developed before the pandemic. After the pandemic broke out, working from home and online conferencing grew at a dizzying speed.
Some things are only temporary changes; I'd bet that keeping 6 feet apart in stores will disappear as soon as there is a vaccine.
Some things hardly change. People still need a ‘roof over their heads’ to shelter them. Now, apply the same way of thinking to investing in the single-family rental market:
What is growing? Renting will keep growing, but at a faster pace. What is temporary? Lenders are pausing deals that were approved only two months earlier. What is not changing? Residential real estate seems to be holding its value.
Economic challenges will drive more people to rent
First, look at the big picture of how COVID-19 is driving growth in the number of consumers who will rent. Before the pandemic, millennials had aged up and were looking for a home with four walls and a yard. Unfortunately, many millennials carry significant student loan debt. This is hurting their ability to buy a home and pushing many of them into renting. The financial impact of COVID-19 will put even more strain on personal finances and will put home ownership out of reach for many. Ultimately, this increases the number of people who want, or need, to rent.
Lenders always take on more risk when the market goes down
Next, why is banks pausing deals a temporary phenomenon? Most lending strategy swings like a pendulum. When economic conditions are favorable, banks start to loosen their policies and accept more risk. When the economy starts to stall, lenders instinctively become more risk-averse.
With current economic conditions heading toward a recession, lenders are staying away from high-risk customers and requiring part of the bill to be paid up front before signing a secured loan agreement, even for customers with pristine credit. We are seeing loans at a 70% loan-to-value / loan-to-cost ratio (LTV/LTC), whereas only two months ago it was 80%.
This does not constitute a new normal. It is simply a normal reaction of lenders in the face of a testing period. When the economy returns to prosperity, lenders will come back toward making financing easier to get.
Homes are still a worthwhile investment
Finally, home values have grown well again after the COVID-19 pandemic in many markets across the country. In Detroit, the median sale price rose 8.5% from April 2019 to April 2020. In Austin, Texas, the median sale price rose 3.2%, and in Atlanta the median sale price rose 8.9%.
That is a good sign for single-family rental investors, because their portfolios are likely to hold their value. Worries about collecting rent remain, but according to the National Association of Residential Property Managers, “over 60% of property managers reported that 91 to 100% of their tenants paid May rent in full and on time.” This means rental cash flow is still positive for most investors.
What this means for the single-family rental real estate market
Analyzing each phase of any business by these criteria (what is accelerating, what is temporary, and what is not changing) provides an objective way to assess change. We will thrive in volatility, in a pandemic, or not at all.
Even with recent changes, investing in the single-family rental market still makes long-term sense. The rise in the share of potential tenants creates a ready market to fill homes and generate cash flow. Durable home values make the single-family rental market a sensible long-term investment. Even if homes lose a little value in the short term, healthy cash flow from rental income will help investors build equity.
In the short term, tighter lending strategies may keep investors on the sidelines. However, doing deals outside traditional banks, such as with credit unions or smaller community banks, may offer investors the terms they need to reach an agreement. And of course, some investors will still be willing to take a 70% LTV/LTC deal.
Looking at single-family rental trends through this lens, instead of leaving the game too early and accepting the so-called new normal, is still an extremely attractive advantage. Yes, we are going through a crazy time. But that does not mean investors can only struggle through. Learn to analyze and adapt to change, and profits will still multiply.
Compiled